← Back to Field Notes

The Honesty Tax: Attention in Exercise and Learning

Sun Jan 11 2026

Attention is the honesty tax that applies to both mind–muscle connection and depth of learning.

Some movements are easy to complete and hard to do. They need more mind–muscle connection not because they are heavier, but because they are easier to fake, and the body excels at taking shortcuts. Most of us have finished a set and sensed something missing. That missing piece is usually called mind–muscle connection, but when you zoom out to cognition it becomes precision load. Precision load is the mental demand required to keep a system honest. The linking thread is attentional control, the ability to keep the right thing active and the wrong thing quiet. It applies to exercise, and it applies to learning.

Mind-muscle connection is often treated as gym mysticism, but in practice it is closer to engineering. It is the art of constraining a system with too many degrees of freedom. It relies on the ability to detect compensation early and shut it down. Research suggests that directing attention internally toward a muscle can increase activation in that muscle, but it is not automatically “better.” If the goal is maximal performance, speed, strength, output, external focus can win. If the goal is hypertrophy or motor control, internal focus becomes more useful. This note is about the latter.

Attention is the mechanism that reduces degrees of freedom until learning can happen.

Most of the time, the body looks for the easiest way to solve a movement. The glute kickback exposes this because the load can be light, the rep can look “done,” and because it feels light, the load is often increased, but the target is easily missed unless attention constrains the system. Common compensations include arching the lower back to create the illusion of the leg going farther back, which quietly leaks glute tension. Another is letting the hip rotate outward, dumping the work into a different line of pull. The most common compensation is the hamstrings taking over, turning the movement into something closer to a hinge pattern as the load rises. In kickbacks, the movement is not the challenge. Honesty is.

Likewise, some concepts are difficult to learn because they do not live on one level. A clear example is understanding how the Transformer architecture works. The Transformer is the engine behind modern large language models, including systems like ChatGPT. Its power comes from learning relationships between tokens and building contextual representations, using attention as a core mechanism. But to truly understand it, you have to hold the stack: tokenization and embeddings, positional information, attention through queries, keys, and values, multi-head structure, residual pathways, normalization, feed-forward layers, and how learning is driven by backpropagation and gradient descent. You cannot just memorize the words. A break in understanding at one layer fragments the chain. The required skill is conscious attentional routing: staying precise about what each component does, and why it exists, in relation to the rest. This is why deep focus is not a personality trait. It is a technique. It is mind–muscle connection for cognition.

A second example is working with retrieval-augmented systems. It is easy to build something that outputs text. The harder truth is whether the system retrieves the right evidence consistently. You can get fluent nonsense and think your system works, the same way you can complete reps and miss the target.

For high mind–muscle exercises, chasing numbers can degrade form. You can avoid that by reducing load, increasing control with slower tempo and pauses, and ending the set when compensation begins. For high-focus concepts, start with a goal and a question. The goal is to explain the idea in your own words in a way a 12-year-old could follow. The question, when anything feels vague, is simple: what problem does this solve?

In both domains it comes down to intentional recruitment and alignment under load. Simple to say. Difficult to live.